On June 3, 1961, someone broke into the Bay Harbor Pool Room in
Panama City, Florida. Some beer and wine were stolen. The cigarette
machine and jukebox were smashed and money was missing. A witness
said he saw Clarence Earl Gideon in the poolroom early that morning.
The police found Gideon and arrested him. He had a lot of change in his
pockets and was carrying a bottle of wine. They charged him with
breaking and entering.
Gideon was poor. He could not afford a lawyer. At the trial, he asked
the judge to appoint a lawyer for him. The judge said no. Gideon argued
that the Sixth Amendment says he is entitled to a lawyer. The judge told Gideon that the state doesn't have to pay for a poor person's legal defense.
This meant that Gideon had to defend himself. He tried hard but didn't
do a very good job. For example, he called some witnesses who helped the
other side more than they helped him.
Gideon was found guilty and was sentenced to five years in jail. He
thought that this was unfair because he had not been given a lawyer. He
asked the Supreme Court of Florida to release him but the court said no.
Gideon kept trying. He wrote a petition and sent it to the Supreme
Court of the United States. When it read what Gideon had written, the
Court agreed to hear his case.
In an earlier case, Betts v. Brady, the Court had ruled
that in state criminal trials, the state must supply a poor defendant
with a lawyer only if there are "special circumstances". These special
circumstances could be that the case is very complicated or that the
person is illiterate or not competent to represent himself. Gideon did
not claim any of these special circumstances. The Court needed to decide
if it should get rid of this "special circumstances" rule. If it did
so, then poor people like Gideon would be given a lawyer if charged with
a felony in a state court.
Questions to Consider
What was Gideon accused of doing?
At the trial, what did Gideon ask the judge to give him? Do you think this would have helped him? Why or why not?
What did Gideon send to the Supreme Court of the United States?
Why did the Supreme Court of the United States agree to hear Gideon's case?
Do you think that poor people who are accused of crimes should be given a free lawyer? Why or why not?